Jared and Ashley -- who got into the St. Patrick's Day spirit by donning skinny green jeans -- celebrated the Irish holiday at the no-frills Phebe's Tavern in Manhattan's East Village. Based on their Twitter feeds, the two parted ways afterwards ... and went on to have very different evenings.
Jared tweeted a photo of himself and former Oklahoma Sooners running back DeMarco Murray that night, writing, "Me and my boy @DeMarcoMurray in NY. I'm showing him around the city. Been drinking all day. Don't judge."
Ashley's night was a little more subdued: "Good food. Good friends. Great day. Now I'm at home watching beauty and the beast haha. Super cool."
Do you think Ashley and Jared would make a good couple or was she better off with Joe?